PPAP for Automotive Molded Parts: Submission Scope and Supplier-Customer Responsibilities

PPAP customer and supplier responsibilities converging at an approval gate

PPAP delays often begin before any documents are compiled. The customer assumes the supplier understands the submission level, the test scope, the sample source, and the approval route; the supplier assumes a standard package is enough.

Before tooling is released, agree the PPAP scope in writing: the governing customer requirements, the reason for submission, the submission level, which of the 18 PPAP elements apply and whether each is submitted or retained, the production-intent run and sample genealogy, laboratory and measurement rules, named owners, timing, and the disposition the customer will issue. The submission level decides what is sent to the customer; it never decides what work may be skipped. A submitted package is not the same as an approved part.

This article is the scope article in the site’s PPAP cluster: what goes into a PPAP submission for a molded part, at which level, and who owns each piece. It does not re-teach the cluster’s other angles — what a T1 acceptance authorizes, FAI vs. PPAP vs. a T1 report, PPAP and sampling costs, and who owns T1 rework.

What does the submission level actually decide — and what does it never decide?

The most expensive misunderstanding in PPAP is treating the submission level as a measure of how much work is required. It is not. The level decides how much evidence physically goes to the customer and how much stays at the supplier, available for review. The underlying work must be prepared for every applicable element at every level.

Agree the level in writing at quotation: the level changes the effort, schedule, and cost of assembling and reviewing the package — but never treat a lower level as permission to do less work. A Level 1 supplier that cannot produce the retained elements on request has submitted an incomplete PPAP, not a smaller one.

The five levels, as described in AIAG PPAP-4 and summarised by Quality-One International, are:

Level What the customer receives When it is typically used
1 Part Submission Warrant (PSW) only; Appearance Approval Report (AAR) also submitted for appearance items Low-risk parts, minor changes, established supplier history
2 PSW, product samples, and limited supporting data Moderate-risk parts where the customer wants physical evidence but has already reviewed the process documentation
3 PSW, product samples, and complete supporting data The default level for new parts, new suppliers, significant changes, and re-submission after rejection — and the default if the customer specifies no level
4 PSW and other requirements defined by the customer Customer-specific programs where the customer names exactly which elements it wants
5 PSW and product samples, with complete supporting data available for review at the supplier’s manufacturing location Critical parts, new suppliers, or programs where the customer wants to review the evidence and the process on site

Three consequences follow. First, if the customer does not state a level, do not assume Level 1; the published default is Level 3, and a late move to Level 3 — or to Level 5, which adds an on-site review and travel — can cost weeks. Confirm the level in writing before quoting, and record who confirmed it and in which document. Second, a level can change during a program: a quality issue can escalate a supplier from Level 1 to Level 3, and a run of successful submissions can de-escalate it the other way. Third, Level 4 is the level most often mishandled: because the customer defines it, the supplier must obtain the customer’s element list in writing before assembling anything. Submitting unrequested elements creates noise; omitting a requested one is a rejection.

A second common misunderstanding is that PPAP approval is the same as production release. It is not. PPAP disposition — approved, interim, or rejected — is the customer’s statement about the evidence package for a defined part revision and process state. Production release is a separate authorization to ship at volume, and it may depend on additional gates such as capacity demonstration or packaging approval. Do not ship on a submitted package, a portal upload receipt, or a signed PSW alone.

Which of the 18 elements apply to a molded part, and who owns each one?

The AIAG PPAP manual (PPAP-4) describes 18 elements that may be required for approval of a production part. Not every element applies to every submission: a build-to-print molder, for example, normally has no Design FMEA obligation, because that element belongs to the design-responsible party. The customer’s requirements decide which elements apply, and the supplier and customer should record that decision element by element rather than relying on the level number alone.

Build the submission as an element-by-element matrix, not as a folder of files. For each of the 18 elements, record whether it applies, whether it is submitted or retained at the agreed level, who prepares it, who reviews it, and its status. The table below is that matrix for a molded part, following the AIAG PPAP-4 submission/retention structure as reproduced in published summaries. Where your customer’s own matrix differs, the customer’s matrix governs.

In the table, S means submit to the customer, R means retain at the supplier and make available on request, and * means as specified by the customer (Level 4). Two cells in published summaries disagree and are flagged in the notes below the table: the PSW at Level 5, and the master sample, checking aids, and design records at Level 3. Confirm both in writing with your customer.

# Element — what it is for a molded part Usual owner L1 L2 L3 L4 L5
1 Design records — customer drawing and CAD data at the released revision; material composition report (IMDS in automotive) Customer releases; supplier holds a controlled copy and confirms feasibility R S S * R
2 Engineering change documents — the approved change notice where the submission is driven by a change Customer approves the change; supplier files the authorized record R S S * R
3 Customer engineering approval — documented customer engineering approval where the drawing or specification requires it Customer issues; supplier obtains and files it R S S * R
4 Design FMEA (DFMEA) — design risk analysis; applies only if the supplier is design-responsible Design-responsible party (usually the customer for build-to-print molding) R R S * R
5 Process flow diagram — every step from incoming resin to shipping, including drying, molding, trimming, secondary operations, inspection, and packing Supplier prepares; customer reviews R R S * R
6 Process FMEA (PFMEA) — process risk analysis for each flow step, with controls Supplier prepares; customer reviews R R S * R
7 Control plan — characteristics, methods, frequencies, and reaction rules derived from the PFMEA Supplier prepares; customer reviews and approves where required R R S * R
8 Measurement system analysis (MSA) — gauge repeatability and reproducibility studies and calibration records for the measurement equipment used Supplier prepares; customer reviews R R S * R
9 Dimensional results — measured results for every drawing dimension, on samples from the production-intent run, identified by cavity Supplier measures and reports; customer reviews R S S * R
10 Material and performance test results — resin certificates, material test reports, and performance test records against the drawing and specifications Supplier collects (including sub-tier evidence); customer reviews R S S * R
11 Initial process studies — statistical process control evidence on critical characteristics, showing a stable process running near nominal Supplier prepares; customer reviews R R S * R
12 Qualified laboratory documentation — accreditation or qualification evidence for any laboratory used, in-house or external Supplier collects; customer reviews R R S * R
13 Appearance Approval Report (AAR) — customer inspection and approval of appearance, where the part has appearance requirements Customer inspects and approves; supplier submits the report S S S * R
14 Sample production parts — physical parts from the production-intent run Supplier produces; customer receives and evaluates R S S * R
15 Master sample — a signed-off reference part used to train operators and to compare against production parts Supplier retains; customer signs off (see note) R R S† * R
16 Checking aids — fixtures, gauges, templates, and models used to inspect the part, with calibration status Supplier prepares and maintains (see note) R R S† * R
17 Customer-specific requirements — the customer’s own forms, formats, and additional requirements for this program Customer defines; supplier complies and files R R S * R
18 Part Submission Warrant (PSW) — the signed summary and declaration of conformity for the submission, one per part number unless the customer states otherwise Supplier signs and submits; customer records the disposition S S S S S†

Notes on the flagged cells. First, the PSW at Level 5: one published summary shows it as submitted, while another describes Level 5 as complete data retained for review at the supplier’s site, with the warrant held with the package. The customer receives the warrant either way; agree the route in writing. Second, the master sample, checking aids, and design records at Level 3: one summary shows them as submitted, another as retained — the master sample stays with the supplier as the production reference, checking aids stay where they are used, and proprietary design detail stays with its owner. Submit the master-sample record and the checking-aid list, and confirm with the customer whether the physical master sample and the aids themselves are expected to travel. The dagger (†) marks those three cells.

Four molded-part points deserve emphasis. First, Element 9: each cavity of a multi-cavity or family mold can differ, so the customer often requires dimensional results for every cavity, not a blended average. Confirm the cavity requirement and the sample count per cavity before the run; Quality-One notes that dimensional layout samples are usually taken at random from a significant production run, usually at least 30 pieces. Second, Element 11: capability evidence is only meaningful after the process is stable and the measurement system is suitable. Review the MSA before the capability calculation, and confirm the customer’s acceptance criteria — characteristic, index, and sample basis — in writing. Do not assume a universal capability value; the customer sets it. Third, Element 10: the resin certificate, grade, colorant, and sub-tier evidence must agree with the drawing, the purchase record,
A certificate for a different grade, lot, or revision is not evidence for this part. Fourth, Element 17: this element most often turns a nominally complete Level 3 package into a rejection, because an OEM’s customer-specific requirements can add forms, change level definitions, or require additional evidence beyond the AIAG list. Identify the applicable document and revision at launch.

The manual itself is licensed; project teams should work from their authorized copy of AIAG PPAP-4 rather than from a checklist copied online. This article summarises the published structure so the buyer and supplier can agree scope; where this summary and the authorized manual differ, the manual and the customer’s requirements govern.

How do you agree the production-intent run and sample genealogy before the run happens?

PPAP evidence should represent the intended production process. A trial run made on a different machine, with prototype material, manual trimming, or undocumented sorting can still produce parts that measure well — and still prove nothing about production.

Agree the run definition before the run, in the same document as the element matrix: mold and cavity configuration, machine, resin grade, colorant, inserts, automation, gauges, operators, rate, packaging, and location. Any departure is a deviation to be disclosed and directed, not a detail to be discovered at review.

Published summaries of AIAG PPAP-4 describe the evidence run as a significant production run — commonly described as 1 to 8 hours and at least 300 consecutive parts, unless the customer specifies otherwise. Treat that as the starting point for the discussion with your customer, not as a rule to apply without asking: the customer may specify a different run length, sample count, or a capacity demonstration such as a run-at-rate trial before warrant submission. Record the agreed run length, sample quantity, and any capacity requirement in the launch matrix. For what a run-at-rate trial should demonstrate, see Automotive Molding Capacity: What a Run-at-Rate Trial Should Demonstrate.

Trace every submitted sample to date and time, resin lot, cavity, process record, inspection report, and test allocation. If samples are conditioned, assembled, aged, or sent to a laboratory, preserve the chain through each step. Random parts from a mixed container cannot support cavity-specific dimensions, and a dimensional result without a cavity identity is, for a multi-cavity mold, an incomplete result.

Name the family-tool and cavity considerations, start-up stabilization, process window, material drying, regrind rule, inserts, and secondary operations in the run plan. Samples that meet dimensions only after undocumented sorting do not demonstrate the intended process. If temporary tooling, manual trimming, prototype material, or a different machine is used, disclose the deviation and obtain the customer’s direction before the run.

Who owns what between supplier, customer, and sub-tier — and where do gaps usually appear?

Responsibility for a PPAP submission is shared, but shared responsibility without named owners is how items fall between the two sides. Apply the division below by naming one accountable owner and one approver for each item, not by writing "supplier/customer" in a responsibility cell.

The customer owns the requirements and the disposition. The supplier owns the process, the evidence, and the truthfulness of the package. Sub-tier evidence remains the supplier’s controlled package. Anything shared needs a named owner on each side.

The customer or design authority must release unambiguous requirements, identify special characteristics and customer-specific rules, answer feasibility questions, define the submission and approval routes, provide mating parts or system-level conditions when needed, and issue a documented disposition — including whether a deviation or interim approval permits shipment, and under what quantity or expiry.

The molding supplier must review feasibility, control documents and changes, build the intended process, qualify measurement systems, collect truthful evidence, retain records, identify nonconformities, and avoid shipment before authorized release. Sub-tier material, laboratory, or component evidence remains part of the supplier’s controlled package when applicable.

Shared items need named owners. Who creates the ballooned drawing? Who approves appearance? Who pays the external test laboratory? Who supplies production-intent mating parts? Who prepares and submits the IMDS declaration? Who performs capacity verification? Who uploads the package and closes review comments? For the IMDS split, see Material Declarations for Automotive Molded Parts.

Two gaps appear most often. The first is customer-specific requirements: a Tier 2 supplier applies an OEM rule that was never flowed down to it, or misses a Tier 1 rule that was. Do not apply an OEM rule to a Tier 2 if it was not contractually flowed down; ask the direct customer to resolve the ambiguity in writing. The second is the laboratory gap: confirm before testing whether the customer accepts the laboratory and whether the test method and acceptance criteria match the drawing — not when the report arrives.

How should the customer review the package — linkage, not document count?

A PPAP package can be complete in page count and still fail, because the documents do not agree with each other. Effective review follows one requirement through the package and checks that every document tells the same story about the same part, revision, process, and samples.

Review by linkage: pick a special characteristic, a material grade, and a revision identifier, and trace each one through every element that should mention it. A green summary page can hide missing cavities, measurements made in the wrong conditioning state, or a capability study run before the measurement system was qualified.

A special drawing characteristic should appear in the risk analysis, the control plan, the inspection method, the measurement-system evidence, the dimensional result, the reaction plan, and the production record. The material grade should match the drawing, the purchase record, the certificate, the process record, the declaration, and the warrant. What a certificate actually declares — and what measured evidence must travel with it — is specified in Certificate of Conformance vs. Measured Inspection Results for Automotive Parts. Revision identifiers must agree across the design record, the change documents, the dimensional results, and the PSW.

Use the buyer review table below as the closure check before the disposition is requested — the same check the supplier should run independently before submission.

PPAP Buyer Review

Review area What to confirm before requesting disposition
Governing requirements Purchase order, drawing and revision, specifications, supplier manual, portal instructions, and customer-specific requirements document and revision are all named and current
Reason and level Submission reason, level (1–5), due date, portal route, and authorized signatories are agreed in writing; Level 4 element list is the customer’s own list
Element matrix Each of the 18 elements is marked applicable / not applicable (with customer agreement), submitted / retained, with a named preparer, reviewer, due date, and status
Design baseline One released revision across design record, change documents, dimensional results, and PSW; DFMEA ownership matches design responsibility
Production-intent run Mold, cavities, machine, resin grade and lot, colorant, inserts, automation, gauges, operators, rate, packaging, and location match the agreed run definition; deviations disclosed
Sample genealogy Every sample traces to date/time, resin lot, cavity, process record, inspection report, and test allocation; conditioning, assembly, and aging steps preserved
Measurement MSA reviewed before capability is judged; dimensional results cover every cavity where required; sample count and run length match the agreed basis
Material and sub-tier Resin certificate, grade, and declaration agree with the drawing and warrant; laboratory qualification confirmed before testing; sub-tier evidence is current
Linkage Special characteristics, material grade, and revision identifiers agree across flow, PFMEA, control plan, inspection, MSA, dimensional results, and records
Disposition Customer’s approved, interim, or rejected status is documented with limits; PSW signature, portal upload, or email receipt is not treated as approval unless the customer’s process says so

What happens after the disposition — interim, rejected, approved, and change?

The disposition is the beginning of the next decision, not the end of the work. Each disposition — approved, interim, or rejected — carries different obligations, and the most common failure after PPAP is treating an interim approval as if it were a full approval.

Record every disposition with its limits, and freeze the approved baseline. Interim approval is conditional and time- or quantity-limited; rejected status requires controlled material and a resubmission plan; approved status freezes the material, source, mold and cavity configuration, process, location, inspection, packaging, and approved deviations — and any proposed change must be evaluated against the customer’s notification and resubmission rules before it is implemented.

Interim approval is conditional. Record the affected part and revision, the quantity or time limit, the open items, the containment, the labeling, the authorized destination, and the exit plan — and do not release further volume on an expired interim approval. For the bounded-authorization logic that also governs temporary deviations, see Temporary Deviations for Automotive Molded Parts.

Rejected status requires controlled material and a resubmission plan: segregate affected parts, record the reasons element by element, and agree which elements must be reworked and at which level the resubmission will be made — a rejection commonly requires resubmission at Level 3. Do not resubmit the same package with a new cover page. For how corrections are classified and who owns the rework, see T1 Corrections vs. Customer Design Changes.

After approval, freeze the baseline: exact material and source, mold and cavity configuration, process, location, inspection, packaging, and approved deviations. The Cpk/Ppk guide shows the per-cavity capability evidence that proves the frozen baseline is actually capable. Evaluate proposed changes against the customer’s notification and resubmission rules before implementation — a resin grade change, a mold move, a new cavity, a process change, or extended inactivity can each trigger a new submission, and the trigger list is the customer’s, not the supplier’s assumption. For the change-control process itself, see Engineering Change Control for Automotive Tooling and Production.

PPAP does not replace ongoing control. The approved package establishes evidence for a defined state; control plans, traceability, maintenance, and change control keep that state effective. If demand, tooling condition, resin, equipment, or design changes, determine the approval impact rather than assuming the old warrant covers it.

Worked Submission Scenario (Illustrative)

An illustrative scenario, with stated assumptions and no cost, lead-time, or acceptance value implied: a Tier 2 buyer is launching a glass-filled nylon electrical housing with two brass inserts, a sealing interface, and one special characteristic — a mating-face flatness callout. Assumptions: the customer has specified Level 3; the molder is build-to-print, so there is no DFMEA obligation; the mold is a two-cavity tool; the customer requires dimensional results for both cavities; and an appearance requirement applies, so an AAR is needed.

At launch, the buyer and the molder complete the element matrix together. Elements 1, 2, 3, and 17 are customer-owned inputs: the released drawing and revision, the change record (none — this is a new part), the customer engineering approval route, and the customer-specific requirements document and revision. Element 4 is marked not applicable with the customer’s agreement, because the molder is build-to-print. Elements 5, 6, 7, 8, 11, 12, 15, and 16 are supplier-prepared and submitted at Level 3. Elements 9, 10, 13, 14, and 18 are submitted with the parts: dimensional results for both cavities, material and performance test results including the resin certificate and the IMDS declaration, the AAR, sample parts, and the signed PSW.

The run definition is agreed before the run: both cavities, the machine class, the resin grade, the insert source, the drying and process window, the flatness inspection method, and the packaging. Samples are traced by cavity and resin lot, and the flatness result is followed through the PFMEA, the control plan, the MSA, the dimensional results, and the reaction plan. At review, the customer finds that the dimensional results cover only one cavity. The package is not approved: the missing cavity is a gap in Element 9, and the molder measures the second cavity from the retained samples and resubmits that element. The level told both sides what would be sent, the matrix told them what had to exist, and the linkage check found the gap before production release did.

Questions to Ask the Supplier

  • Which submission level has the customer specified for this part, in which document, and who confirmed it?
  • Which of the 18 elements apply to this submission, and which are submitted versus retained at that level?
  • Who owns the DFMEA, and does our build-to-print / design-responsible split match the customer’s record?
  • What is the agreed production-intent run — mold, cavities, machine, resin grade and lot, inserts, rate, and location — and what deviations, if any, apply?
  • How are samples traced to cavity, resin lot, process record, and test allocation, and are dimensional results provided for every cavity?
  • Which customer-specific requirements document and revision governs this submission, and where does it change the AIAG defaults?
  • Which laboratory will perform material and performance testing, and has the customer accepted that laboratory and the test methods?
  • Who prepares and submits the IMDS declaration, who approves appearance, and who uploads the package and closes review comments?
  • What is the customer’s disposition route, and what authorizes shipment — the PSW signature, the portal status, or a separate release?

Information to Submit for a Project-Specific Review

  • Controlled drawing and CAD data with revision, material grade, color and appearance requirements, and special characteristics marked
  • Annual volume and release pattern, target timing, and manufacturing location
  • Customer manual, portal instructions, and customer-specific requirements document and revision
  • Required submission level and reason for submission, with the due date and the customer’s element list where Level 4 applies
  • Test matrix, laboratory requirements, and any capacity demonstration the customer requires
  • Mold concept and cavity layout where available, so the run definition and sample plan can be agreed before tooling is released

AutoMoldingPro is IATF 16949 certified and ISO 9001 Certified. Send the drawing, annual volume, material, customer manual, required level, test matrix, and target date through the contact page for a scoped molding quotation — and for the sampling and PPAP cost items to include in the RFQ, see PPAP and Sampling Costs for Automotive Molded Parts.

References

  • AIAG — Production Part Approval Process (PPAP-4): aiag.org — PPAP-4. The AIAG page describes PPAP as the industry standard for defining the production part approval process, to ensure engineering design record and specification requirements are consistently met during an actual production run. The manual is licensed; use an authorized copy.
  • Quality-One International — Production Part Approval Process (PPAP): quality-one.com — PPAP. Lists the 18 elements with descriptions, defines the five submission levels, and notes that dimensional layout samples are usually taken at random from a significant production run, usually at least 30 pieces.
  • SmartAPQP — PPAP Levels 1 to 5 Explained: What to Submit at Each Level: smartapqp.com — PPAP levels. Reproduces the 18-element submission/retention matrix (S = submit, R = retain, * = as specified by the customer) and states the principle that all 18 elements must be prepared regardless of level. Used as the source for the level-by-level table in this article, with the two contested cells flagged in the table notes.
  • Think Plastics — What are PPAP levels 1 to 5, and what goes in a PPAP for a moulded part?: thinkplastics.com — PPAP levels explained. A molded-part reading of the five levels and the 18 elements, grouped by stage, based on Quality-One and AIAG public pages.
Facebook
X
LinkedIn

Wait, We Have Something Special for You!

Join our mailing list and receive a 10% discount on your next mold or CNC project.

Request a Quick Quote

Send your drawings and detailed requirements via:
Email: jerry@ckmold.com

Or fill out the contact form below:

We will contact you within one working day. Please pay attention to the email with the suffix “@ckmold.com”